I have been writing and talking about Ashby Village for over seven years. From the beginning, I thought the village movement (beginning with Beacon Hill Village) was the best idea for helping elders stay in their own homes as they aged. It takes a village to raise a child; it takes a village to care for its elders. Shirley Haberfield and Pat Sussman were the founding mothers for Ashby Village. They did such a great job of laying the groundwork for the development of our village. We met monthly for years planning how we wanted our village to work.
Yesterday Ashby Village celebrated its Fifth Anniversary with a Town Hall meeting. Over 100 people attended. I have always felt that the people I met through Ashby Village are the nicest and most interesting people I know. It launched with 85 members and today is the fastest growing village in the country. Ashby Village now has over 330 members and 345 volunteers, with members range in age from 56 years to 102 years. There are over 20 volunteer committees, from social services to home safety to neighborhood groups. There are several social events each week, many revolving around food. Judy Boe and I are in charge of the Preferred Providers Team and have put together a list of vetted providers so that when members call in, needing help with almost anything, the Ashby Village staff have a vetted provider to refer them to.
There are now villages in most communities in the Bay Area and the movement is spreading throughout the state and nation. Ashby Village is working with San Francisco Village to establish a California coalition of villages.
Happy Anniversary Ashby Village!
Several years ago I worked with a young family whose dream was to develop a multigenerational compound which would house their immediate family plus their extended family in close proximity. We found a small house (900 square feet) on a large lot (16,000 square feet) in El Cerrito which had great potential. Their plan was to live in the small house and develop the additional land so that their mother, father, step-father, sisters and others could join them.
It has taken several years, but the main multigenerational house is now in construction. The four member family will share a new house with the husband’s mom and her new husband. They will rent out the original small house to a sister and the grandpa will live in another building on the property. They will still have an amazing back yard for soccer and other activities. For more information about the design and construction of their home, click here.
I am so proud to have been a part of this endeavor. We looked for the property for about six months. It has taken awhile for them to develop plans and begin construction, but it should be finished by the end of the year.
In the United States, 5.6 % of the population lives in multigenerational housing situations. In the Bay Area and much of California, the rate is 5.7%-10.3%. As house prices continue to go up and stresses on families continue to increase, multigenerational housing offers great potential. Grandparents can help with child care, kids will know their extended families and families can help care for the elders. This is the way families lived for generations. The housing crisis in the Bay Area is providing the stimulus for families to return to solutions which worked before.
Earlier this week I went to the Institute on Aging’s conference, “Big Ideas, Good Work!” This conference was described as “a day-long aging and technology conference addressing how elders, caregivers and senior services are influencing and inventing thoughtful technologies. “ I was excited about going to the conference because I wanted to learn about new devices to help with aging in place.
There were some well-known presenters– Steven Johnson, the co-founder of Aging 2.0 , David Lindeman, the Director of Health for the Center for Information Technology Research in the Interest of Society (CITRIS) and Ann Hinton, Director of Aging and Adult Services. We also heard from several inventors and designers—Jack Lloyd, the inventor of a new home sensor system called SafeInHome, Richard Caro, the co-founder of Tech-enhanced Life and Barbara Beskind, a 91 year old occupational therapist and tech designer for IDEO.
I was disappointed to learn that many of the new technologies are surveillance systems designed to monitor elders who are living alone. Sensors are set up all over the house to keep an eye on mom and dad to make sure that they take their medicine, don’t leave the burner on in the kitchen, go to the bathroom the right number of times, and make sure they keep moving from one room to the next and don’t fall, etc. These activities are reported to the adult children or caregivers on their smart phones. These monitoring devices are important, but they don’t do a lot to improve the elder’s quality of life.
I was most heartened to hear from Richard Caro that he has formed groups of elders all over the Bay Area to review the new technological products that are being developed and to recommend technologies which will help them in their daily living. These groups are called circles or salons. Whereas many of the high tech companies are interested in surveillance systems, elders are interested in better ways to get tight lids off of jars.
One woman who had enjoyed hiking when she was younger wanted to develop a walker that she could use on hiking trails. She found an engineer who helped her with the design. Circle members are trying it out and providing input to help make it better. I think that the circles and salons will be important in the coming years as we continue to explore new technologies to help us as we get older.
One thing I decided at the conference is that I will never use a walker. Barbara Beskind from IDEO walked to the podium using ski poles which she had modified to be more like walking sticks. She told us that elderly people who use walkers have to hunch over when they are walking and this is detrimental to their posture. Pretty soon they cannot straighten up. The walker may prevent them from falling down, but it does nothing to improve their balance. With walking sticks, you stand up straight and swing your arms naturally as you walk. Thank you, Barbara.
TTN-HOME is partnering with Ashby Village for its new 3 month housing series–Aging in Place. Almost everyone wants to age in place—whether it is in his/her/their own home or an apartment or rented house—for as long as possible. Our East Bay community is rich in resources and networks that are creating innovative alternatives and support systems for those who want to seek new ways of living independently or with others as we grow older.
We are going to explore the many ways that people are finding to do this: sharing their home with others by renting out rooms or an apartment, downsizing to a smaller place, buying a house with others, building an Accessory Dwelling Unit in the back yard and others. We will look at safety concerns and making your home accessible as you age. We will discuss topics ranging from planning to support aging independently where you live now; finding alternative ways to age in your community; finding companionship by home sharing with others as well as what kind of housing agreements to put in place.
The meetings will be interactive and include panel discussions, speakers and time to connect with each other.
The monthly meetings will be held on April 25, May 23 and June 27 from 1:30-4:00 p.m. at the First Congregational Church in Oakland (2501 Harrison Street, Oakland, CA 94612). Parking is available at the church. The cost for the series is $45.00. Please RSVP to Lynn Richards, email@example.com.
At the City Council meeting last Tuesday, the council made further revisions to the ADU Ordinance and voted UNANIMOUSLY to accept the revised ordinance. (A unanimous vote by the Berkeley City Council is a rarity.) The ordinance now goes back to staff for further review, but should be on the council agenda for final approval in the summer.
The council made further revisions which include:
- No minimum lot size;
- The ADU may be between 250 square feet and 750 square feet, not to exceed 75% of the area of the main dwelling. Both units may not exceed 40% coverage of the lot.
- ADUs may be on the property line in existing buildings (e.g. gaage);
- Tandem parking is allowed on existing driveways, including the front yard setback;
- Parking waivers if within ¼ mile of a BART station and in an RPP zone;
- No short term rentals, at least one of the units must be owner occupied;
The revised Accessory Dwelling Unit (ADU) ordinance is coming before the Berkeley City Council on Tuesday, March 24 at 7:00 p.m. If you support this ordinance, please show up and say a few words in its defense.
The revised ordinance before the council is a great improvement for homeowners. The major provisions are:
1) Minimum lot size is 3,800 square feet.
2) The ADU may be between 250 square feet and 750 square feet, not to exceed 50% of the main dwelling. Both units together may not exceed 40% coverage of the lot.
3) The setbacks are a minimum 4 feet from the rear and side of the property line, unless the ADU is replacing preexisting buildings on the property line. If ADU is built on property line, doors and windows cannot face neighbors’ property.
4) Tandem parking is allowed if within 1⁄ 4 mile of BART station. There will be no Residential Parking Permit issued to an ADU.
5) Legal property owner shall live in either main dwelling unit or ADU. ADU is excluded from use as short term rentals.
6) ADUs are prohibited in the Environmental Safety Residential (ESR) zone.
The revised ordinance is a great improvement over the current ADU ordinance. It is one of the most promising strategies available to increase the supply of housing in Berkeley without changing the character of our neighborhoods. The ADUs tap into existing systems and cost a fraction of the cost of building a new house. Many housing studies cite ADUs as essential to increasing the availability of senior housing.
ADUs are the best way to enable seniors to age in place in their homes or neighborhoods. For seniors wanting to stay in their own homes, ADUs enable them to do so, with a place for family or caregivers to live nearby in a new backyard cottage or small “in-law” unit. For seniors needing to move to a smaller accessible unit, ADUs allow them to stay on their property and in their neighborhood, avoiding the stress of moving.
Creating an ADU gives seniors many new options –
1) rent the big house or the ADU, providing a source of income to support their caregiving needs;
2) live in the ADU and move family members or friends into the big house so they can help with caregiving;
3) live in the main building and invite a caregiver to live in the ADU, possibly reducing the cost of care.
ADUs offer safe, semi- independent, and inexpensive housing for elderly or disabled relatives, as well as returning adult children. They are true life-cycle housing, supporting flexibility and family stability over time.
2015 is here. The silver tsunami continues to grow. Where are we all going to live? Lots of seniors cannot afford to stay in their homes or apartments when they retire. For many low income senior housing facilities, there is a five year waiting list.
There are several things that I am working on (with others) which will help relieve some of the housing problems.
First is TTN-Home, A Community of Women over the age of 50 Exploring Housing Options. Our planning committee (Arlene Reiff, Lynn Richards, Mona Kreaden, Christine Olsen and me) is getting ready to start the new series. Beginning in January 2015, we will introduce a series of in-depth interactive workshops, designed to build cohorts of women interested in moving forward with their housing issues and concerns within a supportive environment.
The first series of workshops (January, February, and March) will focus on Shared Housing, which includes the options of two or more unrelated people renting or buying a house or apartment together.
The Shared Housing workshops will focus on the building blocks needed to work through the obstacles and issues, enabling participants to take specific steps toward achieving their goals. Part of the process is to enable participants to develop a network of like-minded women who might be interested in looking together at places to buy or rent and/or explore further sharing a home.
The dates of the workshops will be January 24, February 28 and March 28 at 1:30-4:00 in the New Oakland Room at the First Congregational Church, 2501 Harrison Street, Oakland. The cost of the three part series is $45.00. Contact Arlene Reiff (firstname.lastname@example.org) to reserve a place.
Second is the revised Accessory Dwelling Unit Ordinance for the City of Berkeley. Accessory Dwelling Units (ADUs) are self-contained smaller residential units built on the property of a single family home. They may be attached (an above the garage unit or a basement unit) or detached (granny flat, carriage flat, backyard cottage).
ADUs enable communities to grow internally rather than externally, providing additional housing without consuming additional green space. They limit suburban sprawl, provide new housing and can help homeowners financially. They enable seniors to remain in their own neighborhoods as they get older and help multigenerational families live close to one another, affordably and to provide support for young children and elderly family members.
The proposed ordinance is a great improvement over the previous one. As proposed, it will include the following:
1) ADU would be allowed in rear of parcel. ADU allowed in front or side of parcel with Administrative Use Permit (AUP).
2) The subject lot shall have an area not less than 4,500 square feet. Lot size can be less than 4,500 square feet with an AUP.
3) ADU cannot exceed 12 feet in average height (single story) and 640 square feet
4) ADU with minimum of 4 feet rear and side setbacks. Allow ADUs less that 4 feet from property line with AUP.
5) One additional off-street tandem parking space allowed.
6) Eliminate parking requirements for an ADU consistent with the following: 1) ADU is within 1/4 mile of a major transit line, transit hub or BART station, 2) ADU is within a Residential Parking Permit zone and 3) ADU would be prohibited from receiving Residential Parking Permits.
7) Maximum size of ADU is 640 square feet with maximum lot coverage less than 40%.
8) ADU can exceed 40% lot coverage (to a maximum of 55%) with an AUP.
9) Allow for expediting of building permits or over the counter permits if applicant chooses to pay for the expedited service.
Over the past couple of years, I have spoken with many Berkeley homeowners who are interested in building ADUs and look forward to the revised ordinance. This ordinance will come before the Berkeley City Council in February.
Third is new senior housing in Berkeley. Many months ago I wrote about the Burbank Senior Artists Colony which is the most exciting senior housing facility I have seen. From the time I first learned about it, I felt that we needed a Senior Artists Colony in Berkeley. I could not decide how to proceed with this idea and one day wrote an email to the housing developer who built the Burbank project. A few weeks later, they responded and I spoke with the President of the company who told me that they would love to build a Senior Artists Colony in Berkeley. Now I am busy looking for land on which to build the facility and talking with artists and teachers who would be interested in teaching classes there. We are only in the very beginning stages, but I am looking forward to a wonderful new place for Berkeleyans to retire. It will take at least five years to complete the project, but at lease we are getting started. Where would you rather live? A senior housing facility or a senior artists colony?
One of the things that I have always liked about working with seniors is the other people who also work with seniors. I have met so many dedicated and talented people over the years who are passionate about their work with seniors. In the last year, I have been impressed with the people who have been identifying unmet needs among their senior clients and patients and starting their own businesses to provide those needed services.
Elisa Reutinger has many years of marketing and activities programs in retirement communities. She has now formed her own company, Craft a-la-carte. She provides one-on-one 90 minute visits to her client’s homes and provides the inspiration, materials and know-how to help seniors with the arts project of their choice. The activities may include: sewing, embroidering, quilting, felting, dyeing fabrics, doll-making, painting, drawing, jewelry making, bookmaking and crafting with recycled materials. The first class is free. To find out about Elisa’s program, click here.
Elizabeth McDonald is a former realtor and business owner. She has always enjoyed working with seniors and formed her own Senior Concierge service, Thank Goodness. There is almost nothing that Elizabeth will not do for her clients: housework, shopping, driving to appointments, cooking, organizing, helping with moves—anything to help older retired adults stay independent. Her goal is to “help my clients live full, fun, and active lives while fostering independence and dignity.” Click here to find out more about Thank Goodness Senior Concierge.
Two of my friends, Sandi Peters and Cait McWhir have joined with Jenette Northern and Odile Lavault to form Soul 2 Soul-Seniors which provides exceptional and unique services designed to nourish and sustain both the elder and their caregivers.
Sandi’s specialty is sand tray for elders. She uses a box of sand and numberous miniatures to access their inner worlds. She also uses poetry, storytelling, myths and discussion to help caregivers and their loved elder understand and explore the aging journey.
Cait specializes in massage for seniors. This specialized form of massage is appropriate for many seniors. Deeply restorative and relaxing, it can significantly relieve aches, pains, and stiffness, as well as many health conditions associated with aging.
Jenette practices Jin Shin Jyutsu, anancient Japanese form of healing using light finger pressure on specific areas of the body, while fully clothed. The gentleness of this healing art brings relief from pain and theunpleasant symptoms that can accompany aging or disease.
Using the Validation Method, Odile gives caregivers the tools to change themselves so they can enter the personal reality of the person for whom they are caring. With exercises and role-play, Odile teaches how to accept disoriented older people just the way they are in the moment, without trying to change them.
To learn more about the unique services of Soul2Soul-Seniors, go to their website.
In the recent Harvard/AARP Report on Senior Housing, the study concluded that, while there are significant challenges, the potential is there for older adults to have a higher quality of life than ever before and for communities to be more livable and vibrant as a result. It is up to us who are senior service providers and seniors themselves to provide the impetus for improved service delivery.
I have a high school friend, Helen Thompson, who lives in Austin and writes a weekly blog about beautiful and unique houses. Her blog is called Helen Thompson In House. Over the years she has written about some very significant homes, mostly in Texas. Several years ago I told her that I thought she needed to write about some of the lovely universally designed houses that I have been seeing that are built for seniors to age in place.
Last week she did. She posted about an absolutely beautiful pre-fab house in the Sonoma Valley. The architects are Jacob Levy and Gordon Stott of Connect Homes in Los Angeles. Their client is the daughter of a nearly 90 year old mom who had been having some health issues and the daughter wanted to build a house for her mom on her land in Sonoma County. The house is larger than the Accessory Dwelling Units we see here in Berkeley, but offers lots of ideas for building an accessible dwelling for an elder.
Building a pre-fab house is considerably less expensive than building a custom home and takes about one-third of the time. These are very important considerations when building a home for a senior who may not be able to climb stairs anymore and needs a home soon that is accessible for them. Many of them do not need to spend two years working with an architect plus another year of construction before they can move in. When buying a pre-fab house, you know up front how much it is going to cost and how long it will take to install. There are no unforeseen price increases, supply shortages or work delays. The cost of the Sonoma house is $264,000.
The architects, Jacob Levy and Gordon Stott, are starting to build more accessible units in Northern Calfornia and have backyard models (600-900 square feet) as well as larger units like the 1600 square foot home featured in Helen’s article. The average cost for the medium and large size units are about $165/square foot and includes all of the fixtures (lighting, cabinets, appliances, bathroom fixtures.)
The home was also featured in the June issue of Dwell. In addition, Levy and Stott spoke at the Dwell on Design LA Conference in June 2014 and shared their thoughts on universal design and pre-fab houses. Check out Helen’s blog, the Connect Homes website and the Dwell article for more photos of the house. It is truly gorgeous!
TTN-Home had its third meeting with its revised format earlier this week with almost fifty people attending the meeting. If you are looking for creative housing options for seniors in the East Bay, this is the place to be! TTN-Home is sponsored by the San Francisco Bay Area chapter of The Transition Network, a nationwide organization for women experiencing transition in their lives.
Besides the educational presentations and networking opportunities the attendees also receive emails from TTN-Home about housing vacancies, housing wanted and announcements of other housing events occurring in the Bay Area.
Two months ago, we had our first meeting using the new format. I gave an in-depth talk on the Twelve Housing Options for Seniors in the Bay Area. These options include:
Aging in Place Options
- Staying in your own home as homeowner
- Staying in your own home as a renter
- Downsizing to a smaller place (condo, coop, apartment or smaller house)
- Accessory Dwelling Unit in your backyard or a friend’s or family member’s backyard
House Sharing Options
- Buying a house with others
- Sharing a rental with landlord present
- Sharing a rental with no landlord present
Aging in Communities Options
- Multi-generational and Senior Co-Housing
- Limited Equity Housing Cooperative
- Pocket Neighborhood
- Affordable Senior Housing
- Community Care Retirement Communities (CCRCs)
At our second meeting, we had a panel of people who live in: affordable senior housing, a limited equity housing cooperative, a landlord who rents out rooms in her house and a woman who shares a rental with another woman. They talked about their experiences in the various options they had chosen.
The third meeting featured a panel with residents of: a multigenerational co-housing project; a senior co-housing project, (Phoenix Commons), a Continuing Care Retirement Community and a pocket neighborhood. Our plan for next month is to have an Aging in Place panel. The final two meetings of the series will deal with financial issues. We plan to repeat the series of six meetings, beginning in January.
At the recent meetings, attendees spent time determining which options would work the best for them and discussed their ideas and action plans with other attendees. After the panel discussions, the panelists stayed for about thirty minutes to answer additional questions from members of the audience.
The feedback we have received is excellent, the audiences grow every month and lots of people are talking about what they need to do next to achieve their housing objectives. The energy in the room is amazing. We live in the most expensive housing market in the country. We are making a real difference in helping people figure out how to navigate this very difficult market.
The TTN-Home planning committee consists of Mona Kreaden, Christine Olsen, Lynn Richards, Arlene Rieff and me. We are very proud of the work that we have done and also the work that the attendees are doing to meet their housing objectives..